Great Observation
RV7ator said:
Good inspiration for those still riveting, Scott, and in spite of Smiley being in my back yard, I haven't been there this year! Good to see it.
But...I gotta be a cold water scold about something...
You took off uphill. That's a real bad practice around here. Since most people looking at your pix won't realize this, I hope you don't feel singled out since your outcome was no sweat, but I've seen too many near crashes and wrecks, and read of enough dead people who tried to go around too late or take off uphill, to remain silent. I'm concerned about someone from Kansas packing the bathtub, windmill, and kitchen sink recalling the orientation of your pix, who'll attempt the same thing and plant himself in the side of Galena Pass. Downhill's the way out of mountain strips (and uphill landings). If you think the wind's too wrong, don't fly (that's the advice of a past Idaho Aeronautics Director).
John Siebold
Boise, ID
That is a very good point. I should have mentioned that anyone interested in flying in the backcountry can fly into McCall Airport just west of Smiley and Johnson's Creek and get a "crash" course in flying these runways. They will show you the approaches and discuss mountain flying. You can even hire them to make some approaches. Thanks for pointing that out.
But....
That is funny you say that. I was with Gordon (the caretaker), a Maule driver, and two guys who were air traffic controllers watching guys come in and land Sunday morning and take off. The winds were about 10 gusting to 15 or so about 30 deg off centerline from the south (downhill direction). I would say that 1/2 of the planes that took off that day went downhill and half went up hill. I asked Gordon what he typically sees and his words were that it is 6's, but if the winds blow much above 5 or 10 that he always recommends takeoffs uphill and we all agreed. We watched some Cherokees takeoff down hill and couldn't believe they were even trying a downwind takeoff. They were about 100' agl for 3 miles trying to climb. The higher they went, the stronger the winds. The guys that took off to the south (uphill) appeared to climb much quicker and easily made a left crosswind or just kept climbing through the mountains. We all sat there and actually couldn't believe that these people were taking off downhill but that is everyones decision. I did notice that all of us taking off uphill had more horsepower than the guys going downhill.
You are dead on that if the winds are not blowing the downhill takeoff is preferable, but in the winds we had all day and into the night, uphill was the better choice.
Now the best choice is to wait until 6am when the air is cool and there are no winds. At a place like Johnson's Creek or Big Creek that is smartest way. But it comes down to judgement. I took off right after 6pm, the OAT was around 70 deg. and we used about 1/4 the runway and easily climbed straight out. If I was in a Cherokee 140, I would have never tried what I did. I would have waited until the morning.
The downhill/downwind takeoffs we watched appeared to be dangerous. Gordon pointed out to me while they were taking off that windsock on the south is typically different than the one on the north. He says the mountains protect the south end and by the time you get to the north you can have a pretty good tailwind. Just another thing to watch out for.
As for me, the Maule, and two 182's that took off that night, we all went uphill into the wind and had no issues. I actually kept the plane a little lower on takeoff so RaNae could take a picture of the campsite as we flew by.
I did notice a few memorial stones there at the camp. Not sure if they lost their lives at that airport but it does make you think. This type of flying is more risky but just like anything with a little training it is just another runway.
Good observation though, thanks for pointing that out and bring up the discussion. If you have the new
Carbon Cub, sounds like you could takeoff across the runway.